Star Wars on trial : science fiction and fantasy writers by David Brin

By David Brin

Debates at the authenticity of the Star Wars franchise and the hero-or-villain prestige of George Lucas are on the middle of those essays by way of bestselling science-fiction authors. The tremendous approval for the films has ended in the formation of robust feelings in the technological know-how fiction neighborhood at the strengths and flaws of the movies, exemplified right here through David Brin's assaults and Matthew Woodring Stover's safety of the flicks. This excessive exam of the epic works addresses a wide variety of issues�from politics, faith, and the saga's total good judgment to the impression of the sequence on bookshelf house in addition to science-fiction movie. The query Is George Lucas a hero for bringing technology fiction to a mass viewers or a villain who does not comprehend the style he is operating for? is mentioned earlier than a last "Judge's Verdict" at the greatness�or weakness�of the franchise is reached.

About the Author

David Brin is the writer of 15 novels, together with Earth, Startide Rising, and The Uplift War, and diverse brief tales. he's the recipient of 3 Hugo Awards and one Nebula Award. He lives in Encinitas, CA. Matthew Woodring Stover is the writer of the movie novelization Stars Wars: Revenge of the Sith, in addition to Blade of Tyshalle and Star Wars: Shatterpoint. He lives in Chicago, IL.

Show description

Read or Download Star Wars on trial : science fiction and fantasy writers debate the most popular science fiction films of all time PDF

Best pop culture books

What Ifs? Of American History

Did Eisenhower keep away from a showdown with Stalin through no longer taking Berlin sooner than the Soviets? What may have occurred if JFK hadn't been assassinated? This new quantity within the extensively praised sequence offers interesting "what if. .. " situations via such well-known historians as: Robert Dallek, Caleb Carr, Antony Beevor, John Lukacs, Jay Winick, Thomas Fleming, Tom Wicker, Theodore Rabb, Victor David Hansen, Cecelia Holland, Andrew Roberts, Ted Morgan, George Feifer, Robert L.

Sound and Music in Film and Visual Media: A Critical Overview

Sound and Music in movie and visible Media: A severe Overview is a accomplished paintings defining and encapsulating options, matters and purposes in and round the use of sound in movie and the cinema, media/broadcast and new media. Over thirty definitive full-length essays, that are associated through highlighted textual content and reference fabric, compile unique examine through the various world's best students during this rising box.

Aboriginal self-determination. The Whiteman's dream

Land rights, welfare and tradition have locked aborigines out of the great existence. Land has turn into a burden, welfare has turn into disabling, undesirable behaviour is wrong for tradition. there's a means out. Aborigines needs to abide by way of an identical principles as some other Australian — search out possibilities, examine difficult, and loose themselves from a tradition of undesirable behaviour.

The Boston Cosmopolitans: International Travel and American Arts and Letters, 1865–1915

This publication strains the development of cosmopolitanism from the non-public event of a gaggle of artists and intellectuals who lived and labored in Boston among 1865 and 1915 to entire works of enormous paintings that formed public area.

Additional info for Star Wars on trial : science fiction and fantasy writers debate the most popular science fiction films of all time

Example text

In order to defend the aristocratic rights of another. Imagine Achilles refusing to accept his ordained destiny, taking up his sword and hunting down the Fates, demanding that they give him both a long life and a glorious one! Picture Odysseus telling both Agamemnon and Poseidon to go chase themselves, then heading off to join Dae dalus in a garage start-up company, mass-producing both wheeled and winged horses, so mortals could swoop about the land and air, like gods-the way common folk do nowadays, so unaware what they are part of.

A marvel of collaborative technological progress. Even if their start-up fails and jealous Olympians crush Odysseus/ DaedalusCorp, what a tale it would be! Can this attitude work in stories? Consider those lowbrow but way fun television series Hercules, Buffy and Xena. Though they wore all the trappings of fantasy-swords and magical spells-each episode told a morality tale that was fiercely pro-democracy, egalitarian, hubristic and rambunctiously antiaristocratic. ) This new storytelling style was rarely seen till a few generations ago, when aristocrats lost some of their power to punish irreverence.

Just pause and think about it. Arguably, the most persistent and incessant propaganda campaign, appearing in countless American movies, novels, myths and TV shows, preaches a message quite opposite to the one we associate with Joseph Campbell. A singular and unswerving theme, so persistent and ubiquitous that most people hardly notice or mention it. And yet, I defy you to name even half a dozen popular movies that don't utilize its appeal. Yes, that theme is suspicion of authority-often accompanied by its junior sidekick tolerance.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.68 of 5 – based on 47 votes